MODIS with Warren et al for Artic region

Comparison of MODIS with APPX (AVHRR Polar Pathfinder Extended), and MODIS minus APPX cloud frequency for day and night.  Data from August 2001 through July 2002.  First slide is daytime MODIS.

Nighttime Comparison

Comparisons of one year of MODIS to a 31-year surface data set from Warren et al., as reported by Key.  Curves are almost the same shape except for February and March.  Obviously, daytime obs in the winter months are coming from the southernmost parts of the Arctic where there are supposedly more clouds.  But this also may indicate too many clouds in terminator regions processed by the daytime MODIS algorithm.